The German Coal Conundrum

The German Coal Conundrum

German Coal Conundrum
Jun 06, 2014 by Arne Jungjohann, Craig Morris
Place of Publication: Washington
Date of Publication: June 2014
Number of Pages: 25
License: CC-BY-NC-ND

The status of coal power in Germany’s energy transition

Germany has drawn international attention for its energy policies in recent years. The term Energiewende – the country’s transition away from nuclear power to renewables with lower energy consumption – is now commonly used in English.

The focus, however, has recently shifted to the role of coal in Germany. Over the last two years, media both in Germany and abroad have spoken of a possible “glowing future” for coal power and a “coal comeback” in Germany (Schultz 2012, McCown 2013). From the decision to phase out nuclear power, observers conclude “that domestically produced lignite… is filling the gap” (Birnbaum 2013). Indeed, statements made by German politicians over the past decade also suggest that these coal plants were intentionally built to replace nuclear plants.
Here, we have the coal conundrum of the Energiewende: is Germany building new coal plants to replace nuclear despite the country’s green ambitions? This paper finds that the concern is based largely on a temporary uptick in coal power in 2012/13 (due to a cold winter and greater power exports) and on a round of new coal plants currently going online.

An in-depth look reveals that coal is not making a comeback in Germany. The current addition of new coal projects in Germany is a one-off phenomenon. Recent projects started in 2005-2007 as part of an overall trend in Europe caused by low carbon prices and upcoming stricter pollution standards for coal plants. New coal plants in Germany are unrelated to the nuclear phaseout of 2011 after the Fukushima accident.

Instead, renewables have more than offset the nuclear plants shut down. During the nuclear phaseout (until the end of 2022), this trend can be expected to continue, though the specific outcome depends on the actual growth of renewables and demand for power in Germany and neighboring countries.




Table of contents:

1. Executive Summary 4

2. Overview of coal use in Germany 5
a) Final energy: coal in the power sector 6
b) Net exports, “residual load”, and emissions 10

3. Reasoning behind new coal plants 11
a) Little incentive to invest in renewables 16
b) Utilities now regret investments in new coal plants 16

4. Lignite in safe position until 2020s? 17
a) EU policy: stricter emission standards for coal plants 17
b) Civil society’s call for a coal phaseout 17
c) Capacity crunch: less MWh from more MW 18

5. Conclusion 19

6. Bibliography 20


Add new comment

Add new comment

Ike Bottema

Really? So tell us what happens when the wind isn't blowing? Will Germany go dark? I don't think so. Fire up those coal plants because without energy storage, that's the only option left.

Christiane Pakula

Dear Madam, dear Sir,

I have read this really interesting report. The diagram on page 7 shows the generation and export of energy and also the energy demand of the domestic sector. Maybe I have missed it, but, I cannot find an explanation why the demand of energy decreases in 2009. The graph seems to follow the decrease of the generation in 2009. I would be very grateful for a short explanation.

Thank you very much in advance
Christiane Pakula